The Ultimate Guide to Buying a Pre-Owned Rolex Submariner

There are few watches as universally recognized—or as endlessly discussed—as the Rolex Submariner. It’s a design so balanced that it has barely changed in over half a century, and a symbol so iconic that even people who’ve never worn a watch know what it looks like.

If you’re considering adding one to your collection, you’re not alone. The Submariner is arguably the most sought-after pre-owned luxury watch in the world, and it sits at the crossroads of craftsmanship, history, and value retention.

At Watches Etc., we’ve seen nearly every version of the Submariner pass through our hands—from vintage aluminum-bezel models to the latest ceramic-clad evolutions—and we’ve learned what separates a smart buy from a costly mistake.

Here’s how to navigate the world of pre-owned Submariners like a pro.

Why Buy a Pre-Owned Submariner?

Let’s start with the obvious: you’re not just buying a watch—you’re buying an asset. Rolex has an unmatched reputation for holding (and often increasing) value over time.

Buying pre-owned offers a few distinct advantages:

Immediate Availability. Authorized dealers can have multi-year waitlists for popular steel Submariners. On the pre-owned market, you can own one today.
Better Selection. Want a discontinued reference like the 16610 or a no-date 14060M? Pre-owned is your only option.
Potential Value Upside. Certain Submariners—especially transitional models and those with tritium dials or unique patina—can appreciate over time.

In short, buying pre-owned gives you freedom of choice, access, and a better understanding of true market value.

Understanding the Submariner Lineage

The Submariner story begins in 1953. Originally designed as a diver’s tool, it quickly became the gold standard for sport watches. Over the decades, Rolex has refined the Submariner without ever losing its DNA.

A quick overview of key generations:

Ref. 5513 (1960s–1980s): A vintage legend. No date, matte dial, and domed plexiglass crystal. Collectible and full of character.
Ref. 16610 (1986–2010): The modern classic. Sapphire crystal, aluminum bezel, and a perfect bridge between vintage and modern Rolex.
Ref. 116610 (2010–2020): The first ceramic Submariner, featuring the “maxi case” and improved durability.
Ref. 126610 (2020–present): Subtle redesign with a slimmer profile and updated movement (Caliber 3235).

Each era offers something distinct: vintage charm, transitional balance, or cutting-edge tech. The best one for you depends on what kind of collector—or wearer—you are.

What to Look for When Buying Pre-Owned

The difference between a great deal and an expensive mistake often comes down to details.

Here’s what we recommend checking before you buy:

1. Authenticity and Provenance

Always verify that the watch is 100% authentic. That means factory parts, correct serial and reference numbers, and ideally, original paperwork or a service history.

At Watches Etc., every Submariner we sell undergoes a complete authentication process—movement verification, part inspection, and timing calibration—so you can buy with total confidence, even if the watch doesn't still have its original warranty papers.

2. Condition Over Completeness

Boxes and papers are great, but condition is king. A well-preserved Sub without papers is often a better buy than a worn-out example with a box set.

3. Original Parts

Replacement dials, bezels, or hands can impact value. If you’re shopping for a collector piece, originality matters. For daily wear, Rolex service parts are perfectly acceptable.

4. Service History

A Submariner should be serviced roughly every 5–7 years. A recent Rolex Service Center (RSC) receipt is gold—it confirms authenticity and gives a two-year warranty.

5. Market Price

Prices fluctuate, but generally:

Pre-owned ceramic Submariners (114060/124060, 116610/126610): $12,000–$15,000
Aluminum-bezel classics (16610/14060): $9,000–$11,000
Vintage models (5513/1680): highly variable, depending on condition and rarity

Shop our collection of Rolex Submariners now!

Spotting Red Flags

Counterfeit Submariners have become extremely sophisticated. Here are the biggest warning signs to watch out for:

The second hand “ticks” rather than sweeps.
Poor engraving or font inconsistencies.
Incorrect magnification under the Cyclops lens.
Display case-back (Rolex doesn’t use them).
Prices that seem too good to be true.

If you’re ever unsure, walk away—or better yet, let a professional evaluate it. At Watches Etc., we routinely authenticate watches purchased elsewhere to help collectors buy safely.

Which Submariner Is Right for You?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here, and that’s part of the fun.

The Classicist: Go for a no-date 14060 or early ceramic 114060. Clean, balanced, and pure tool-watch DNA.
The Modernist: The current 126610LN or LV (“Starbucks”) offers improved movement, proportions, and wearability.
The Collector: Seek out transitional or out-of-production references like the 16800, tritium-dial 16610, or the 116610LV "Hulk". These can represent strong long-term investment potential.
The Statement Maker: Precious metal models like the white gold “Smurf” or yellow gold 116618 "Bluesy" are luxury icons with undeniable wrist presence. The all-stainless steel 116610LV "Hulk" variant with it's Sunray-finished green dial fits this category too!

Maintaining Your Submariner

Owning a Rolex is one thing; keeping it pristine is another.

Servicing: Every 5–7 years by an authorized watchmaker.
Cleaning: Wipe regularly with a microfiber cloth and rinse under warm water if worn in salt or chlorine. Around once a month, scrub the entire watch with dish soap and warm water to get rid of any built-up grime, etc.

A little care goes a long way—Rolex designed the Submariner to last generations, not years.

Buying From a Trusted Source

The most important factor in any pre-owned watch purchase is trust.

At Watches Etc., every Submariner is authenticated, serviced if needed, and backed by our one-year warranty. Many of our newer models still retain a good portion of their factory Rolex warranty! Our team treats every piece like it’s going into our own collection, because if we wouldn't buy it, why would you?

We believe buying a Rolex should feel exciting, not stressful—and that starts with confidence in who you’re buying from.

Final Thoughts: The Submariner as a Lifetime Watch

The Submariner isn’t just another luxury watch—it’s the benchmark. It’s the rare piece that transitions effortlessly from a dive boat to a boardroom, and it tells a story that only deepens with age.

Buying pre-owned opens the door to that story. Whether you’re picking up your first Rolex or adding another chapter to your collection, the key is simple: buy the watch you’ll actually wear and enjoy.

Because in the end, that’s what a Rolex Submariner was built for.

Back to Journal